Humble Pie Butter Tart Factory & Pizzeria

The Humble Pie is a popular, home-style bakery and pizzeria located at the south end of Lake of Bays, in beautiful downtown Baysville - perfectly positioned for travellers on route to Algonquin Park and other popular tourist destinations. Founded in 2010, by owner/operator Michelle MacIsaac, the bakery has a loyal and dedicated following and has become part of the Muskoka cottage family tradition.  We maintain strong relationships with our community, regional tourism, local businesses, the media, and our suppliers.  Famous for our delicious butter tarts, we also offer a variety of fruit pies, deep dish meat pies and quiche, pastries, breads and custom made Italian inspired pizzas.  The bakery partners with Ontario based and local artisans offering honey, maple syrup, coffee, and craft condiments.

Maintaining consistency and quality we continue to evolve and experiment with industry trends. We are recognized for our generosity and the work we do in our community creating awareness and raising funds for local charities.

During the busy summer season customers are encouraged to call in advance to place orders, which helps guarantee customer satisfaction.